A Comprehensive Guide to Mattress Thickness

Why Trust Best Mattress Brand

Our proficient team of sleep science coaches, engineers, and product evaluators rigorously inspect hundreds of mattresses using our unique product methodology. Each article is scrutinized for precision, citing only credible sources. Systematically reviewing our content and recommendations, we align with the latest scientific literature and expert insights. Our top-rated mattresses have been personally evaluated and highly rated.

Choosing the right mattress can be overwhelming with all the factors to consider—comfort, firmness, materials, and more. 

But one often overlooked factor is mattress thickness, which plays a crucial role in determining the overall comfort, support, good night’s sleep, and durability of your mattress. 

What Is Mattress Thickness?

Mattress thickness also referred to as mattress height or depth, refers to the vertical measurement from the top of the mattress to its bottom. 

This dimension is essential because it directly impacts how supportive and comfortable the mattress will be, and how easy it is to get in and out of bed.

The standard thickness for most mattresses falls between 8 and 12 inches, with 10 inches being the most common. 

However, there is no one-size-fits-all answer, as different sleepers have different preferences, and the ideal mattress thickness varies based on body type, sleeping position, and personal comfort.

Types of Mattress Thickness (By Category)

Let’s discuss deeper into what each of these categories means for the sleeper.

Low-Profile Mattresses (<8 inches)

Low-profile mattresses are typically thinner than 8 inches and are best suited for temporary bedding solutions or specific bed types like bunk beds, trundle beds, or fold-out sofas. 

These mattresses are often made with fewer layers, which makes them less supportive and less durable than thicker options. However, they are lightweight, easy to move, and great for compact spaces or short-term use.

Standard Mattresses (8-12 inches)

Most mattresses fall into the 8–12-inch thickness range, making them the most common type. These mattresses typically offer a balance of comfort, support, and durability. 

Within this range, the thickness and construction vary based on the type of mattress (e.g., innerspring, memory foam, or hybrid).

Thick Mattresses (12-16 inches)

Thicker mattresses, measuring between 12 and 16 inches, are often marketed as luxury options. They provide extra cushioning and support, making them a popular choice for heavier sleepers or those who prefer a plush, soft sleeping surface. 

These mattresses often feature multiple layers of materials, including high-density foam, latex, or pocketed coils, to enhance comfort and support.

Extra-thick mattresses (16+ inches)

Mattresses thicker than 16 inches are considered extra-thick and are designed for specific needs, such as for extremely heavy individuals or those who desire maximum comfort. 

These mattresses often feature intricate multi-layered constructions, combining memory foam, latex, innerspring coils, and other materials. While they offer exceptional comfort and support, they can be cumbersome and costly.

Factors Determining Mattress Thickness

The overall depth of a mattress is determined by the combined thickness of its internal layers, which can include foam, coils, or other materials. While many mattresses consist of two primary layers—the comfort layer and the base layer—higher-end models may feature three or more layers to enhance performance. 

1. Comfort Layer

The comfort layer is the topmost section of the mattress and directly affects how it feels to lie on. It typically consists of softer materials like memory foam, latex, or pillow top padding. 

The primary purpose of the comfort layer is to cushion the body, relieve pressure points, and ensure proper spinal alignment. 

Its thickness can range from 1 to 5 inches, depending on the mattress type. A thicker comfort layer generally results in a softer feel, while a thinner one may offer more firmness and support.

• Material: Memory foam, latex, or hybrid materials contribute to how plush or firm the comfort layer feels.
• Thickness: More thickness means more contouring for the body, ideal for side sleepers, while thinner comfort layers suit stomach or back sleepers needing firmer support.
• Cooling properties: Many comfort layers incorporate cooling gel or breathable materials to enhance temperature regulation, preventing overheating during sleep.

2. Base Layer

The base layer, also known as the support layer, forms the foundation of the mattress. It is typically much denser and thicker than the comfort layer, ranging from 5 to 7 inches or more.

The purpose of this layer is to provide the structural integrity of the mattress, ensuring that it maintains its shape and offers long-term durability. It also supports the sleeper’s body weight, distributing it evenly to prevent sagging and discomfort over time.

• Material: High-density foam, innerspring, or hybrid coils are commonly used for base layers. Innerspring bases offer more bounce, while foam bases provide more stable, motion-isolating support.
• Thickness: A thicker base layer enhances the durability and firmness of the mattress. For heavier individuals or those who prefer a firmer feel, a thicker base layer is essential.
• Support: This layer ensures that the mattress remains stable, supporting the spine and other pressure points evenly, which is crucial for maintaining proper sleep posture.

Both the comfort and base layers work together to create the overall feel, support, and durability of the mattress, making them crucial in determining the mattress’s thickness and overall performance.

What to Consider When Choosing Mattress Thickness

Choosing the right mattress thickness goes beyond just personal preference—it depends on a number of factors, including body weight, sleeping position, health conditions, and the type of bed frame you have. Let’s explore these in more detail.

1. Body Weight

Your body weight has a significant impact on the type of mattress thickness that will suit you best.

Light Sleepers (<130 lbs.)

People who weigh less than 130 lbs. do not require very thick mattresses, as they exert less pressure on the bed. A thinner mattress (8-10 inches) is usually sufficient to provide the necessary support and comfort. 

Thicker mattresses may feel too firm for light sleepers, as they won’t sink into the layers enough to experience proper contouring.

Average Sleepers (130-230 lbs.)

Most people fall into this weight category and tend to find comfort with mattresses in the 10-12-inch range. These mattresses provide a balance between comfort, support, and durability.

Heavy Sleepers (>230 lbs.)

Heavier sleepers need thicker mattresses (12 inches or more) to provide the necessary support and prevent sinking too deeply into the mattress. Thicker mattresses also tend to last longer for heavier individuals, as they are more resistant to sagging.

2. Sleeping Position

Your sleeping position is another key factor in determining the ideal mattress thickness.

• Back Sleepers: Most back sleepers benefit from a medium-firm mattress that is around 10-12 inches thick. This thickness provides enough support to keep the spine aligned while offering comfort for the lower back.
• Side Sleepers: Side sleepers often prefer a thicker mattress (12-16 inches) that allows for more cushioning at the shoulders and hips. This thickness helps alleviate pressure points that can develop from side sleeping.
• Stomach Sleepers: Stomach sleepers generally require a firmer, thinner mattress (8-12 inches) to keep their body aligned and prevent their hips from sinking too deeply, which can strain the lower back.

3. Health Considerations

People with certain health conditions may require specific mattress thicknesses to enhance comfort and support, especially those suffering from back pain or arthritis. Choosing the right mattress thickness is crucial to managing discomfort and improving sleep quality.

• Back Pain: Individuals with chronic back pain often benefit from thicker mattresses (10-14 inches) because the additional layers provide more support and contouring. Thicker mattresses, particularly those with memory foam or hybrid constructions, cradle the body and help maintain spinal alignment. This reduces pressure points and alleviates pain.
• Arthritis: People with arthritis may also prefer thicker mattresses that offer better cushioning. A mattress with multiple layers helps distribute body weight evenly, reducing stress on sensitive joints. This can be particularly beneficial for side sleepers with hip or shoulder pain.
• Mobility Issues: Conversely, those with mobility issues might opt for thinner mattresses, generally around 8-10 inches thick. Thinner mattresses make it easier to get in and out of bed without straining or needing to climb up too high.

4. Type of Mattress

Different mattress types have unique constructions that influence their thickness. The material composition, support systems, and comfort layers vary, leading to different optimal thickness levels for each type.

• Memory Foam Mattresses (8-14 inches): Memory foam mattresses typically range between 8-14 inches in thickness. Thicker memory foam options (12+ inches) are more suitable for heavier sleepers or side sleepers, as they offer deeper contouring and pressure relief. Thinner memory foam mattresses may be better for back or stomach sleepers, who often prefer firmer surfaces with less sinkage.
• Innerspring Mattresses (8-12 inches): Innerspring mattresses rely on coil systems for support and are often between 8-12 inches thick. Since the coil systems provide the bulk of the support, these mattresses don’t need as much thickness as foam models. However, if you prefer a plush surface, you may want a thicker innerspring mattress with additional comfort layers.
• Hybrid Mattresses (10-16 inches): Hybrid mattresses combine the support of innerspring coils with the comfort of foam or latex layers. They tend to be thicker (usually 10-16 inches) to accommodate the multiple layers. Hybrid mattresses provide a good balance of support and comfort, making them versatile for various body types and sleeping positions.
• Latex Mattresses (9-12 inches): Latex is a durable and supportive material, so even thinner latex mattresses (9-12 inches) can provide excellent support and comfort. Latex is naturally buoyant and resilient, offering a firm yet pressure-relieving surface. A thinner latex mattress can still offer great support, especially for back and stomach sleepers.

5. Bed Frame Considerations

Your bed frame can influence the optimal thickness of your mattress, as certain frames are better suited to specific mattress heights.

• Platform Beds: Platform beds are typically lower to the ground and don’t require a box spring. As a result, thicker mattresses (10-14 inches) are ideal because they provide enough height and support when placed directly on the platform. A thinner mattress on a platform bed may feel too low and could compromise support.
• Adjustable Bases: If you use an adjustable base, it’s recommended to use mattresses that are 8-12 inches thick. This thickness range allows the mattress to bend and move freely with the adjustable base. Thicker mattresses may be too rigid and may not conform well to the movement of the base, limiting its functionality.
• Slatted Frames: Slatted bed frames require a mattress thick enough to prevent sagging between the slats. Typically, a mattress thicker than 10 inches is sufficient to prevent any dip or sagging, ensuring the mattress provides consistent support. A thinner mattress may not offer enough structural integrity when used on slatted frames.

6. Durability and Longevity

Thicker mattresses generally last longer than thinner ones because they have more layers of material to distribute wear evenly over time. 

Durability is an important factor to consider when investing in a mattress, especially if you want it to last for many years.

Mattresses that are at least 10 inches thick tend to be more durable due to their multi-layer construction. 

The extra layers of comfort and support help to distribute body weight more evenly, reducing the likelihood of sagging or indentations over time. If durability is a primary concern, investing in a thicker mattress could be a wise choice.

While thinner mattresses may not last as long as thicker ones, they can still be durable if made with high-quality materials. 

However, they may be more prone to sagging or wearing out quickly because they have fewer layers to absorb pressure and distribute weight.

Impact of Mattress Thickness on Sleep Quality

The thickness of your mattress directly affects several key elements of sleep quality, including comfort, support, and durability.

1. Comfort

The thickness of a mattress plays a significant role in determining overall comfort. A thicker mattress is typically considered more luxurious because it contains more layers of foam or other cushioning materials. 

These layers contribute to a softer and more pleasant feel, which can improve sleep quality by offering a higher level of comfort and relaxation.

Side sleepers, in particular, benefit from a thicker mattress because they need additional pressure relief at the hips and shoulders. When lying on their side, a person’s body weight is concentrated on these smaller surface areas, which can lead to discomfort if the mattress is too firm or thin. 

A mattress with adequate thickness provides enough cushion to relieve this pressure, ensuring a more restful sleep.

Stomach and back sleepers may not require as much thickness for comfort, as their weight is distributed more evenly across the mattress. 

However, they may still appreciate the plush feel that comes from a mattress with thicker comfort layers, especially if they prefer a softer sleep surface.

2. Support

Support refers to how well a mattress keeps your spine aligned and distributes your body weight evenly. The thickness of a mattress affects its ability to provide proper support, especially for individuals with specific body types or sleeping habits.

• Heavier Individuals: Thicker mattresses are better suited for heavier individuals because they provide more layers that can support the body without sagging or losing shape. If a mattress is too thin, it may compress under the weight of the sleeper, leading to improper spinal alignment and increased pressure on certain body parts. For this reason, people who weigh more tend to sleep more comfortably on mattresses that are at least 10-12 inches thick.
• Lighter Individuals: Lighter individuals may not benefit as much from a very thick mattress. Since they exert less pressure on the mattress, they may not sink in deeply enough to activate the contouring layers. If the mattress is too thick, they might feel as though they are “floating” on top, which can result in less effective support. A thinner mattress may actually provide better support for lighter individuals because it allows them to experience the mattress’s full contouring potential.
• Spinal Alignment: Proper spinal alignment is crucial for a healthy sleep posture, and thicker mattresses with multiple layers often provide better contouring to the natural curves of the spine. However, the mattress thickness should match the sleeper’s body type and weight to avoid poor posture or discomfort.

Thus, the right mattress thickness balances the need for support and body contouring based on a person’s weight and sleeping position.

3. Temperature Regulation

The thickness of a mattress can also affect how well it regulates temperature during sleep. Mattresses that are too thick, particularly those made with memory foam, are more likely to trap heat, leading to an uncomfortable and warm sleeping environment.

• Heat Retention in Thicker Mattresses: Thicker mattresses tend to have more material, which can restrict airflow and trap body heat. Memory foam mattresses are especially prone to this, as the dense foam can retain warmth. For people who tend to sleep hot, a thick memory foam mattress may exacerbate this issue, causing restless sleep or frequent wake-ups due to overheating.
• Cooling Technologies: If you prefer a thicker mattress but are concerned about overheating, consider looking for mattresses that incorporate cooling technology. Some modern mattresses include gel-infused memory foam, open-cell foam, or breathable covers that promote airflow and wick away moisture. Hybrid mattresses, which combine foam with innerspring coils, also offer better airflow and heat dissipation than all-foam models, helping to balance the comfort of a thicker mattress with cooler sleep conditions.
• Thinner Mattresses for Better Airflow: If temperature regulation is a primary concern, opting for a slightly thinner mattress can also help. Mattresses that are 8-10 inches thick generally allow for better airflow, reducing the likelihood of heat buildup during the night. Latex mattresses, in particular, are known for their natural breathability and can be a good choice for those who sleep hot.

Thick Mattresses vs. Thin Mattresses: Which is Better?

Both thick and thin mattresses offer distinct advantages, depending on individual preferences and needs. Let’s break down the pros and cons of each to help you decide which is best for you.

Which Should You Choose?

• Go for a Thick Mattress if… you prioritize comfort, support, and luxury. They are a better choice for those with back pain, side sleepers, or individuals seeking a long-term investment.
• Opt for a Thin Mattress if… you’re on a budget, need something lightweight, or have limited space. Thin mattresses are perfect for temporary use or minimalist setups but may lack the support needed for daily use by heavier sleepers.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) 

How does mattress thickness affect sleep quality?

Mattress thickness influences several aspects of sleep quality, including comfort, support, and temperature regulation. A thicker mattress provides more layers for cushioning and support, which can enhance comfort and spinal alignment. However, thicker mattresses can also trap heat, affecting temperature regulation.

Is a thicker mattress always better?

Not necessarily. While thicker mattresses provide more cushioning and support, they might not be ideal for everyone. Lighter individuals may not sink in enough to experience proper support on a very thick mattress. Additionally, thicker mattresses can trap more heat, making them uncomfortable for hot sleepers.

What mattress thickness is recommended for back pain?

For individuals with back pain, a mattress around 10-12 inches thick is often ideal. This thickness provides enough support and contouring to keep the spine properly aligned, reducing pressure on the back.

Do thicker mattresses last longer?

Yes, thicker mattresses tend to be more durable because they have more layers to distribute wear evenly over time. A mattress that is at least 10 inches thick is likely to last longer than thinner options, especially if made from high-quality materials.

Can a mattress be too thick for certain bed frames?

Yes, some bed frames, such as adjustable bases, may not work well with overly thick mattresses. Mattresses thicker than 12 inches may be too rigid to move freely with an adjustable base. Platform beds, on the other hand, can support thicker mattresses (10-14 inches) without issue.

How does mattress thickness impact temperature regulation?

Thicker mattresses, especially those made with memory foam, tend to trap more heat, leading to a warmer sleeping environment. If you sleep hot, consider a thinner mattress or one with cooling technology, such as gel-infused foam or hybrid construction, to improve airflow and temperature regulation.

Can a thinner mattress provide good support?

Yes, a thinner mattress (8-10 inches) can still provide good support, especially for lighter individuals or back and stomach sleepers. The key is to choose a mattress with high-quality materials that maintain their shape and offer enough firmness.

What Thickness of Memory Foam is Best?

The best thickness for memory foam depends on your needs. A 10-12 inch mattress is ideal for most sleepers, offering a balance of comfort and support. For heavier individuals or side sleepers, a thicker mattress (12-14 inches) provides extra cushioning.

Should I choose a different mattress thickness if I have an adjustable base?

Yes, for adjustable bases, it’s best to choose a mattress that’s between 8-12 inches thick. This allows the mattress to flex and adjust with the base without compromising support or comfort.

Conclusion

Choosing the right mattress thickness is a critical decision that affects your overall comfort, sleep quality, and long-term health.

While standard mattresses in the 8-12 inch range will suit most sleepers, factors such as your weight, sleeping position, and health conditions should guide your decision. 

Thicker mattresses (12-16 inches) offer added comfort and support for those who need them, while low-profile mattresses may work well in specific situations like children’s beds or guest rooms.